Built from doctrine. Checked against the paragraph.
BulletForge encodes the regulation (AR 623-3, DA PAM 623-3, FM 6-22) and the
hard-won judgment of someone who's seen every shape of NCOER a rating chain can
pass back. Every bullet cites the standard it supports. Tier markers calibrated against the
actual paragraph, not a vibe.
Inflated draft
Outstanding leader with great potential who consistently demonstrates exceptional results across all areas of responsibility.
Outstanding leader with great potential who consistently demonstrates
exceptional results across all areas of responsibility.
BulletForge
o consistently ran NCOPD all four quarters; mentored eleven Soldiers to NCO leadership, six on first-look; curriculum adopted brigade-wide
o consistently ran NCOPD all four quarters; mentored eleven Soldiers
to NCO leadership, six on first-look; curriculum adopted brigade-wide
Each draft checked against the rule that governs it
| Rule |
Inflated draft |
BulletForge |
| Starts with a small letter “o” DA PAM 623-3 ¶3-6b(4) |
No |
Yes |
| Two lines or less DA PAM 623-3 ¶3-6b(1) |
Yes, 2 lines |
Yes, 2 lines |
| No potential language in a rater comment AR 623-3 ¶1-40c |
No, “great potential” |
Yes |
| Specifics that support the box check DA PAM 623-3 ¶3-6b(5) |
No |
Yes, 4 quarters, 11 Soldiers, 6 first-look |
| Shows the tier paragraph it meets |
No |
¶3-11a(4) |